I am perturbed by the fact that an ex-convict - for a drug related offence, no less - can so simply be assimilated back into government healthcare. From his conviction in June 2006 to date, it has barely been 9 months, including the period of incarceration. Notwithstanding, he has been vouched for by his peers and other doctors and has managed to be 'an active volunteer'. (Note: These facts were sourced from the CNA report)
My question is - under what possible justifications can a trainee doctor with limited reference be supported by testimonials? Also, how actively could he have volunteered in that short time to display 'his passion for the medical profession'? I am not convinced by these arguments and feel that the SMC Disciplinary Committee have taken the issue too lightly. When the researcher Simon Shorvon was dealt with so severely when he allegedly conducted himself unethically not long ago, I find that there is no reason not to administer an equally harsh punishment to an inexperienced doctor with such serious criminal misgivings.
As this doctor will be put in a government hospital treating members of the general public, I feel that it is clearly a matter of public concern and should be accordingly debated in a public forum. I am with the opinion that the justifications be openly declared by the SMC and the referees for the character of this ex-convict-cum-doctor be willing to reiterate their stand publicly. To think that one day my life or the lives of my loved ones may be in the hands of a possible drug-addict is nothing short of alarming.
The implications of this development are also equally troubling. By virtue of the same 'passion for the profession' and 'peer testimonials', will a teacher who has molested a female student under 'tremendous exam stress' be allowed to return as a teacher in an all-boys school? Will then a former convicted CEO be re-employed into another charity based on his years of success and demonstrated 'passion for fund-raising'? When these 2 scenarios are a firm impossibility, then how can a convicted doctor practice medicine?
I would expect the SMC and even MOH to detail the justifications and precedent(s) for this current state of affairs, or, urgently review the decision with the public’s safety and well-being in mind. I have nothing against giving second chances, but taking a chance with positions of such huge responsibilities is going beyond the limit.
Thank you
Ganga (Mr)
Profile : http://www.gangasudhan.20m.com
Articles : http://ganga.proboards41.com
CNA Report - http://www.channelnewsasia.com
Simon Shorvon case - http://www.todayonline.com
